Bravo Cura
Celebrating José Cura--Singer, Conductor, Director
Carmen @ La Scala
Carmen @ La Scala |
|||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
|
Carmen "is assigned the place of the contemporary martyr in a bigoted village" -- Emma Dante
"Solitary, introverted, distant from everything, [Don José is] like a unassailable fortress in the middle of a desert." -- Emma Dante
"In Micaela's following there's a priest...who, in the first act, celebrates her wedding with Don José." -- Emma Dante
"Carmen is surrounded by children, like a cow followed by a swarm of flies." -- Emma Dante
"What's the attraction that his pure and uncontaminated nature triggers off?" -- Emma Dante
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Gripping Carmen with José Cura and Elina Garanca in La Scala, Milan
Report from Zsuzsanna Suba
28th March 2015
Emma Dante’s Carmen production was premiered in La Scala, in 2009 and she harvested many attacks for her vision. After some years of absence, the renewed run of her production owned an exciting, new cast this spring. Seeing José Cura’s charismatic Don José together with Elina Garanca’s Carmen was the main motivation for me to take my first trip to La Scala in Milan and this gave the opportunity to wave to the lovely Dolomites and Trento too. It required a careful and timely organization with great question marks. The performance of 28th March welcomed a sold-out house and I had a good view of the stage from the second balcony. Fortunately every element of this trip contributed well to meet with a wonderful experience.
In my opinion, it was an amazing and unusual production from Emma Dante. I can understand a certain level of frustration from the audience or critics, because some work was needed on the recipient side to understand and absorb the concept and many ideas of the production. However critics tried to use the usual clichés of easy journalism and their existing formal prejudices about the production or protagonists to misjudge the recent Carmen performances. There was a total contradiction between what I experienced live in La Scala (on 28th March) and what I read in the official reviews about this spring run. It is much easier to refuse something and write about it negatively than to accept new approaches and real fulfilments even if it would surprise you. So if you were ready to absorb new influences, the reward was enchanting thanks to the vocal and acting quality and commitment of the leading trio.
The actor-singers, Elina Garanca (Carmen), José Cura (Don José) and Elena Mosuc (Micaela) fully transmitted and utilized the merits and creative contents of Emma Dantes’s production and created a wonderful dramatic music theatre through the whole night. They subordinated themselves to the director’s imagination and they did a huge and creative job in this context bringing the essential mysticism, passion and vitality to the scenes. They acted and sang wonderfully together adding great emotional honesty and involvement to the drama. The final applause lasted for more than nine minutes, though at that moment I felt, that the protagonists would deserve even more celebration, it speaks well about the success of the performance.
It wasn’t just the enjoyment of beautiful music and voices, but we experienced stunning, high voltage theatre as well! By the end of the opera we became familiar with the strange figures or props (priest, altar boys, nuns, procession, cross, children, etc.) which escorted the main protagonists, except Don José who remained lonely throughout the drama. Their secret dreams or the symbols of their characteristic living environment were projected on the stage in the form of beautiful, often surreal or grotesque pictures or scenes. These were associated mainly to the direct, visual messages or motivations of the characters, including freedom or bound, carefree love of life or loneliness, danger or tradition, predestined fate or death using some distorted symbols of Catholic religion too. These added elements were somehow questionable, vulgar or sarcastic, sometimes really poetic, but inevitable it gave dynamism and more layers to the story – at least to think about it. Somehow we noticed a desire for uncontrolled and particular female domination in the story too. However I always felt an ironic wink with the director. I admit that I didn’t understand everything about the director’s purposes, but I found her tools refreshing and entertaining. So I fully enjoyed it except the delineation of an exaggerated and barbaric, violent fight among the gipsy girls and soldiers.
The first Act was very strong indeed, we were entertained well by crowded, eventful, shocking or fiery scenes: the changing of the guard with violent children who acted strangely, the marching and flower bathing of factory girls, the big entrance of Carmen with flirting and provocative dance and attractive, flexible voice in Elina Garanca’ first, well placed and choreographed solo (Habanera). In the latter, most spectacular scene I enjoyed the men’s foolish, gaping or wondering, different reactions depending on whether they belonged to the villagers or soldiers. Only José Cura’s Don José remained stiff and unaffected even so when Carmen’s flower was thrown to his chest.
One of my favourite parts of this opera is the Micaela-Don José duet and I’ve got everything what I wanted in the following scene. The visual concept was strange but touching at the same time. During most of the time of the duet (“Parle-moi de ma mère!”), Don José and Micaela stood quite far away from each other on the stage. They sang out their own thoughts or dreams independently, not really caring about the other, rarely seen friend; there was no physical touch or kiss between them. José Cura stood in the rear end of the stage and conjured an incredible melting, haunting tenor voice as he remembered to the passing memories of his homeland. He wasn’t looking at Micaela, he turned his whole body away from her facing toward the audience and sang his words with sweet-tempered, smiling face. He showed a beautiful sense for the line of music and integrity of his feelings. Elena Mosuc’s Micaela did the same in the centre, front position, her strong and sheer and vibrant soprano sounded quite determined and confident to delineate her vision and desire of arranging her marriage with Don José in the village. Her modest, black dress was suddenly changed to an ornate white wedding dress, but her dream was locked forever in the cage of her huge, white bridal veil, which was thrown to her head by the priest standing behind her. Though they got closer to each other by the end of the duet, Don José’s hesitating hand for a closer touch indicated his decision about the future. The projection and realization of this long duet, especially José Cura’s appealing singing style reminded me to the imitation of a dreamlike, frozen, never ending moment, as if time would stop until the sweet melody of the beautiful duet finished. I longed for listening to it more, but after the applause, the story continued.
The next lovable scene came with Carmen’s second great solo (Seguidilla) when she was left on the stage as a prisoner guarded by Don José with a long rope. Garanca’s proud and tricky Carmen played with the rope and used it masterfully together with her creamy, caressing voice, body language and forced body contact as the weapons of her irresistible seduction to capture her man and make him her accomplice. Overcoming his initial, strong and cool resistance and rejection, José soon got involved in this game with exploding carnal pleasure not hiding his intoxication of love any longer. José Cura increasingly filled his unrestrained, soft vocalism with impatient passion. It beautifully boasted about his first declaration of love and they sealed it with a hot kiss of great position. Then we saw their clever and sudden action including Carmen’s escape and Don José’s punishment. They deserved the applause after the duet and at the end of the first act.
The second act was even more torrid and you didn’t want to miss any single moment on the stage. Carmen and her gipsy companion appeared now in the underground tavern (!) of Lillas Pastia, where joy of life and danger were equally present. With Carmen’s leading voice and dancing power, their mad, fresh and dynamic song (“Les tringles ..”) stirred the atmosphere of the stage. Even Escamillo (sang by Vito Priante) managed to perform his big entrance (Votre toast ..”) effectively with the help of the choir and orchestra too as he marched through the long table of the tavern. Though his pale and dry baritone was less attractive than I would expect for a great show, he was a good actor and was able to delineate the essential features of the character for which Carmen would tempted later. The brave execution of the ensuing quintet also contributed with a nice stamp and great impact to the show.
Then we were enchanted by all the three phases of the exciting and wonderful, long encounter of Carmen and Don José during their big solos and duet. The arrangement was again strange but exotic. Carmen, our host invited Don José to an orgy of food, candles and young gipsy girls and then she pampered him exclusively with erotic dance and seductive song (“Lalalala ”). José enthusiastically admired his woman sitting on the ground and then lying on his back, he was still under Carmen’s influence when he heard the first sound of the trumpet from the distance. As Carmen’s solo progressed you could observe how much our Corporal started to feel her anger and watched her mad determination for more engagement desperately. His hesitation soon changed into a more and more decisive action to leave the plot. Their voices blended beautifully together expressing the contrast between Carmen’s dangerous, selfish mood and José’s heartfelt and impassioned words about his duty and love.
Then Carmen turned her back on him injured and we had the pleasure to take delight in our tenor’s balmy and open-hearted solo. José Cura addressed his Flower Song to his woman’s refusing back unmoved, kneeling on his heel. Only the audience could see his remorseful, pleading face and the growing passion and love in his eyes while he sang the lines with sincerity and disarming artistic arch. The song was the poetry itself giving all his soul in the closing, free high note at the end. Loud bravo shouts and short applause granted him for this wonderful achievement. Carmen’s first shy reaction didn’t prevent her to continue her cruel behaviour in their finishing dramatic quarrel. Though they engaged each other in a long kiss, a moment later José pulled himself out from her embrace nervously and took an angry and impetuous farewell from Carmen. It was a nice moment when Zuniga’s arrival stopped the action and the lovers tried to hide the obvious signs of their previous, passionate meeting. In the next exciting fight of the two men Zuniga was defeated and it was clear that José had no other choice than joining to the smugglers with shining, triumphant voice on Carmen’s side. This was Don José’s last, happy moment in the opera. Great applause granted them again.
I think it was the director’s intension that we didn’t see and witness that great, overwhelming love scene between Carmen and Don José in this second act. Perhaps she wanted to demonstrate Carmen’s hectic, impulsive view of life, that in one moment she gives everything to his man, while in the other moment she deprives him off her love. The latter was more pronounced in the third act, where not only Carmen, but the whole camp hated Don José. It was a memorable scene when Elina Garanca turned Carmen’s game with the cards into a really frightening, dramatic scene with her unique performance seeing and accepting her fate and death. Parallel to this, the smugglers’ camp which appeared as a camouflage of living human-trees before, was transformed into a bleak cemetery by a touching vision when little, oblique crosses grew up from each lying figure.
I also greatly enjoyed the manly duet and fight between Don José and Escamillo which was displayed in an unusual mood and in a very convincing way by the singers. It revealed Don José’s dark side, his blind instinct and quick-tempered, aggressive nature. Escamillo’s tall and elegant figure was the winner of their fight in both physical and moral sense. He managed to elude his body from his rival’s attack and knife, he even could kill Don José, but he left him alive with a small wound and thus he humbled him with his skilful and shameless tactic during the duel. Our Don José was quite ungrateful with him when he tried to attack the toreador unexpectedly, from behind his back. This action was unfair and it highlighted his uncontrollable and dangerous temper.
Micaela’s arrival and her applauded airy solo conquered us not only because of Elena Mosuc’s splendid vocalism. But it coupled with a gripping visual effect as suddenly her white shawl was transformed into a large, white blanket and her young but gray-haired girl became Don José’s mother lying behind it in her deathbed. This also gave the strength and power to José to threaten Carmen to death with his darkest voice and violence and to return home with Micaela. We produced huge applause at the end of this act.
In the beginning of the fourth act I liked the colourful procession of toreadors and picadors, their imaginative, rhythmic knee-dance. The last, long duet of Carmen and Don José (“C'est toi!- C'est moi!”) again represented one of the highpoints of the evening, a real tense and dense drama with the help of the main protagonists’ distinctive and colourful vocal acting. The surrounding environment and props of this scene already indicated the tragic outcome of their final encounter. José Cura’s performance was simply breath-taking here in his pure fragility and then in his equally raw brutality. His initial, beautifully projected, heart rending, pleading words to his woman carried mildness, love, great passion and intensity. It touched the whole audience in the theatre, except Elina Garanca’s Carmen, though he even threw himself on his knees in front of her. Carmen rejected him with growingly evolved coldness and wild determination seeking her death according to the prophecy of the cards. This cruel behaviour enraged Don José so much that he attacked her violently while we’ve heard and seen his furious, dark vocal and vulgar actions when he tried to rape her twice. At the second attempt lying on the ground, Carmen managed to pull out José’s knife and offered it to him to kill her. It surprised José so much, that he sobered for a moment and let Carmen to escape. But when Carmen threw his ring away in the next moment, he was shocked and humiliated to such an extent that he sliced her throat from behind with a quick, unpredictable movement and the drama finished.
Then the audience happily offered a long celebration with intense applause and bravi toward the stage for almost ten minutes greeting all the protagonists, the choir, orchestra and conductor (Massimo Zanetti) for this nice evening. We were also very fortunate to meet José Cura and other friends backstage where he generously let us harvesting great souvenirs and a gentle talk in the night.
|
|
|
|
|
Last Updated: Friday, December 06, 2019 © Copyright: Kira