Bravo Cura

Celebrating José Cura--Singer, Conductor, Director

 

 

 

Operas:  Peter Grimes

Monte Carlo

Home | Up


 

Peter Grimes

 

Reviews

 

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  “José Cura designed, in co-production with the Opera of Bonn, this Peter Grimes.  The artist assumed a protean role, singing the title role, directing, setting the staging and designing the costumes.  He created a satisfying production because he understood the scope of the complex psychology inherent the role. Of an unusual physical strength, with a voice almost too beautiful for the role, caught between vulnerability and contradictions, we could imagine [Cura’s] Grimes wreaking havoc in an English port bar…an image rejected by the Argentine to create ambiguity [and present] a man who had suffered.  With an imagination rich enough to inspire the desire to live in better conditions yet constantly facing frustrations, José Cura’s Grimes marvelously expresses the torments that tear at this solitary fisherman, favoring the figure of the hopeless, the enlightened poet (it is necessary to hear his hallucination in the song in the tavern) and the surly but touched lover.  Neither hero nor villain but doubtless subtlety disruptive…..” 

(Director) “José Cura designed an exemplary show.  A regular on the Monegasque scene and last year’s formidable Tannhäuser, José Cura designed, in co-production with the Opera of Bonn, this Peter Grimes.  He created a satisfying production because he understood the scope of the complex psychology inherent the role.  The ensemble was encased in good-taste classicism, the movement of the crowd is natural without awkward poses, and the star tenor approaches the hero by giving him the nuances of a Lord Byron, a sort of an uncultivated intellectual who seems animated by a poetic gift. ”  Podcast Journal, 26 February 2018, Christian Colombeau

 

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  “What to say about José Cura? Audience members commented that they were incredibly stunned by the new performance of the Argentinean already basking in the glow of his previous appearances on the Monegasque stage:  the now legendary Stiffelio in April 2013 and more recently but equally astonishing Tannhäuser.  When the talent of an operatic artist is able to arouse genuine emotion, his repertoire can leave Giuseppe Verdi and elegantly rub shoulders with Richard Wagner and then venture with unparalleled charm into contemporary theater.  From his impressive "Alone, Alone, Alone with the Dead Child" signifying his initial despair to his final "Here you are, nearly home" through his daydreaming "In dreams, I built myself some kindlier home" in the presence of his apprentice, José Cura impresses us by the irreproachable accuracy of his tone and forces admiration by the successful vocal and dramatic expression of this inner chaos, of this incapacitating psychological surge that finds its anchor only in death.”   

 (Director) “A magnificent Peter Grimes at the Monte Carlo opera…  After a series of sold-out performances at the Bonn opera (co-production), Peter Grimes premiered at the Salle Garnier on Friday, 23 February.  Tenor José Cura, adored by the Monegasque opera scene, interpreted the title role while taking care of the staging, the sets, and the costumes:  the result was a pessimistic vision of a fishing village on the east coast of England that Dickens would probably not have rejected.” Musicologie, 24 February 2018, Jean-Luc Vannier

 

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  “Previously appearing in the opera house last year in Tannhäuser, the Argentine tenor embodies a Peter Grimes trapped in his internal prison.  With his massive body folded in on itself, his clumsy and brutal gestures, Cura’s Grimes in a ball of nerves ready to explode at any moment, evincing a physical impossibility to exist, to live.  He must be heard singing a capella, his eyes fixed and misted, suddenly fragile and ready to die.  What’s more, Cura displayed dazzling vocal health, be in in the middle or high register, modulating his instrument with ease, alternating sumptuous piannissimi with heroic power with a naturalness that commands admiration.  This new role is a good one to add to Cura’s incredible list of achievements…. ” 

(Director) “To mount Peter Grimes is to question the inner drama:  is he a victim, an executioner, or both at the same time? In this new production at the Opéra de Monte Carlo, directed by star tenor José Cura, the first option prevails, with a choice of a powerful confrontation between the fisherman and the crowd, clusters of humans moving in beautifully orchestrated choreography.  Cura offers a traditional and realistic vision of the village (with the inn and church mentioned in the libretto) in the seaside town in Suffolk.  Although very present in the music, the sea is less so in the staging, although there is a boat and the many fishing nets that litter the ground at the opening of the curtain are then raised to be suspended in the flies.  Here they will stay for the duration of the show, before being reused for the last scene, when the nets come down little by little during the last chords, trapping all the inhabitants within the village.”  Opera Online, 28 February 2018, Emmanuel Andrieu

 

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  “The Monte Carlo Opera presented a Peter Grimes whose insistent and oppressive intensity is perfectly rendered.  José Cura offers an interpretation that embodied Peter Grimes.  His imposing and fluid voice is torn in the high-pitched notes when he approaches them from his chest voice, which reinforces the theatrical characterization of the character’s pain.  Conversely, high notes emitted in mixed voice are strong even though they may seem more fragile, especially in the "Now the Great Bear and Pleiades" where the delicate beauty of the vocal line is paramount.  On the other hand, his voice rushes into the air during the drinking scene that follows, like a flash of lightning.”  

(Director) “The Monte Carlo Opera presented Britten’s opera Peter Grimes whose insistent and oppressive intensity is perfectly rendered. José Cura, both directoring and starring in the title role in this production, offered a classic and literal point of view on the work, whose purpose, still very modern, does not need updating to find echo today. The Prologue puts Grimes on the stage in front of a white curtain on which are projected the other characters in shadows.  The rest [of the action] takes place in a building doubling as the tavern and the church, above which looms a kind of lighthouse that serves as Grimes’home.  Installed on a turntable to quickly vary its aspects, the concept worked perfectly.”  Ôlyrix, 21 February 2018, Damien Dutilleul

 

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  “In the title role, [Cura] defies any putative stylistic archetype, perhaps because of the non-concealable Latin characteristics of his vocality in which an emotionally physical engagement emerges.  His sincerity in the role exposes the ambivalence of this marginal man, brutal and skin-deep, rejected by the community, without yielding to some simplistic aggressive male pride.  José Cura undoubtedly constitutes the pivot around which the drama is articulated...” 

(Director) “Co-produced with Bonn Opera, where it was presented in the spring of 2017 before moving to the Salle Garnier in Monte Carlo, José Cura’s reading of Britten’s Peter Grimes (Cura also sings the title role) is not limited to the salt spray and accursed solitude of the sailor.  The setting he designed does not deny the certain realistic pragmatism, enhanced by the dim lighting, [but doesn’t allow] this illustration to become overwhelming.  The rotation of the stage reveals different facets of the unique setting where the promontory of the lighthouse and the hut of the fisherman abut a low structure, serving in turn as a tavern or church, according to the scene, the sanctuaries for the borough, irritants for the harshness of Peter Grimes.  But the effectiveness of the staging serves as social illumination more so than the poetic abstraction to which some would be tempted to reduce the Britten work because of the evocation of the mystery of the seas. 

Even the restraint of the Prologue, during which Grimes appears alone in front of a blue-gray canvas like the sea under the moon and on which the shadows of the court are projected, the magistrates and townsfolk reduced to voices as in mental ruminations, shapes the premises of an interpretation; [the direction] is sensitive to the psychological complexity of the character and the situations that restores the dialectic between nature and society, at evidenced in both the score and the libretto.  It is not necessary to dispense with the letter to allow the spirit live.  No transposition, no alibi of modernity: Cura’s work focuses first on highlighting the incarnations.” Anaclase, 28 February 2018, GC

 

 


 

The drama and tragedy of Benjamin Britten’s operatic masterpiece, Peter Grimes, is brought to the Riviera this month by Monte-Carlo Opera – with internationally renowned tenor José Cura in the title role.

This haunting tale of a somewhat dark and mysterious seafarer, set on the bleak and windswept coast of East Anglia, is the work which is credited with having established Britten as the leading British composer of his generation, and – according to the Britten-Pears Foundation – the work which “almost single-handedly revived English opera” when it premiered at Sadlers Wells in London in June 1945. It was commissioned by the Koussevitzky Music Foundation and “dedicated to the memory of Natalie Koussevitzky”, wife of the Russian-born American conductor Serge Koussevitzky.

Inspired by a narrative poem, The Borough, by Suffolk poet George Crabbe, the opera has a libretto adapted by the English poet, novelist and playwright Montagu Slater, and tells the of the uneasy relationship between Peter Grimes and the villagers of the town where he lives – the ‘Borough’ of Crabbe’s poem. Although the Borough is a fictional place, it shares many similarities with Britten’s hometown of Aldeburgh.) Following the death of Grimes’ apprentice during a storm at sea, the fisherman is presumed by the local community to have been responsible, and although Grimes is cleared at the coroner’s inquest, he is no longer considered trustworthy, and when his new apprentice is found dead at the foot of the cliffs, Grimes’ life falls apart and he heads for a tragic breakdown.

Both Britten and his partner, the tenor Peter Pears, were deeply involved in drafting the story of the opera, and keen for Grimes to be portrayed less as the villain that Crabbe had described, and more as a victim of both fate and society. Ultimately, though, audiences are left to draw their own conclusions about Grimes, about what really happened, and the judgment of the other leading characters in the opera.

 

Click on the photo above to watch the Peter Grimes Trailer from the Bonn Production, 2017

 

José Cura – a much sought-after tenor, and regarded as one of the greatest exponents of the Italian and French traditional repertoire – is famed for more than his operatic performances, which include those of Verdi’s Otello, Sansón in Saint-Saëns’ Sanson et Dalila, Cavaradossi in Puccini’s Tosca, and more recently, appearances in Wagner’s Tannhäuser and Peter Grimes. He is also a trained composer and conductor, an opera director and a stage designer, and in fact has to his credit the design and costumes in this Monte-Carlo Opera production.

As a conductor, José Cura has appeared with orchestras such as the London Philharmonia, the London Symphony, the Vienna Philharmonic, Sinfonia Varsovia, the Toscanini Orchestra, and the Hungarian Philharmonic. His stage design and direction for productions such as Sanson et Dalila, La Rondine, Cavalleria Rusticana and Pagliacci have been highly praised by both critics and audiences, and his eminence as a director of distinction has been confirmed by his staging of Otello at Teatro Colón in Buenos Aires, a new production of Puccini’s La Bohème for the Royal Swedish Opera, his Turandot at the Opéra Royal de Wallonie, and Peter Grimes at the Bonn Opera House.

The role of the schoolteacher, Ellen Orford – whom Grimes had hoped to marry – is sung by Danish soprano Ann Petersen, described by Des Opernglas as “a true discovery”, and whose performance as Elisabeth in Wagner’s Tannhäuser – with Daniel Barenboim at the Staatsoper Berlin – as “superlative” by the Sunday Express. An ensemble member of the Royal Danish Opera, Ms Petersen has also appeared on the stages of the Vienna State Opera, the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, Milan’s Teatro all Scala and Opéra National de Paris.

Balstrode – one of Grimes’ few supporters – is sung by Egyptian-born baritone Peter Sidhom, – a role which he has sung at the Opéra Bastille and the Grand Théâtre de Genève. His “wonderfully dark Scarpia adds a riveting stage presence to his resonant voice” wrote Anthony Holden in the Observer, following a performance of Puccini’s Tosca at the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden.

This Monte-Carlo Opera performance is led by British conductor Jan Latham-Koenig, Chief Conductor and Head of the Kolobov Novaya Opera Theatre of Moscow, where recent performances include Donizetti’s Lucia di Lammermoor, Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde and Richard Strauss’ Salome.

Maestro Latham-Koening leads the Monte-Carlo Philharmonic Orchestra, and the Monte-Carlo Opera and Chorus (director Stefano Visconti), in a new production of Benjamin Britten’s Peter Grimes – a co-production with Opera Berlin [sic / with Opera Bonn] – at the Salle Garnier from February 20th to 28th.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   
 

 

        

 

                            
 

 

                       

 

 

 

   
                                      
   

   

           

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 

       

 

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Curtain Call Photos

 

 

 

 

 

 

Reviews

Note:  These are machine-based translations.  We offer them only a a general guide but they should not be considered definitive.

 

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  Co-produced with Bonn Opera, where it was presented in the spring of 2017 before moving to the Salle Garnier in Monte Carlo, José Cura’s reading of Britten’s Peter Grimes (Cura also sings the title role) is not limited to the salt spray and accursed solitude of the sailor.  The setting he designed does not deny the certain realistic pragmatism, enhanced by the dim lighting, [but doesn’t allow] this illustration to become overwhelming.  The rotation of the stage reveals different facets of the unique setting where the promontory of the lighthouse and the hut of the fisherman abut a low structure, serving in turn as a tavern or church, according to the scene, the sanctuaries for the borough, irritants for the harshness of Peter Grimes.  But the effectiveness of the staging serves as social illumination more so than the poetic abstraction to which some would be tempted to reduce the Britten work because of the evocation of the mystery of the seas. 

Even the restraint of the Prologue, during which Grimes appears alone in front of a blue-gray canvas like the sea under the moon and on which the shadows of the court are projected, the magistrates and townsfolk reduced to voices as in mental ruminations, shapes the premises of an interpretation; [the direction] is sensitive to the psychological complexity of the character and the situations that restores the dialectic between nature and society, at evidenced in both the score and the libretto.  It is not necessary to dispense with the letter to allow the spirit live.  No transposition, no alibi of modernity: Cura’s work focuses first on highlighting the incarnations.

In the title role, [Cura] defies any putative stylistic archetype, perhaps because of the non-concealable Latin characteristics of his vocality in which an emotionally physical engagement emerges.  His sincerity in the role exposes the ambivalence of this marginal man, brutal and skin-deep, rejected by the community, without yielding to some simplistic aggressive male pride.  José Cura undoubtedly constitutes the pivot around which the drama is articulated...  Anaclase, 28 February 2018, GC

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  After a series of sold-out performances at the Bonn opera (co-production), Peter Grimes premiered at the Salle Garnier on Friday, 23 February.  A “fascinating human adventure,” a director of the Monte Carlo Opera told us, as tenor José Cura, adored by the Monegasque opera scene, interpreted the title role while taking care of the staging, the sets, and the costumes:  the result was a pessimistic vision of a fishing village on the east coast of England that Dickens would not have rejected.

Within the prologue, the three acts and five luxurious musical interludes, it is necessary to retain an image of a triptych for this dark history:  in the first part, the dull omnipresence of the sea is always threating, literally a tempestuous, uninterrupted flow of notes—the winds and bass instruments placed to the right of the maestro—and superbly personified by the Monte Carlo Philharmonic Orchestra.  Then, the pre-eminence in the score, the polyphonies representing the devastating disaster of public opinion with striking interventions of the chorus of the Monte Carlo opera:  "Merciless tide, spare our shores," "The old Joe left with young Joe" or still more "Arrogant and proud, we will destroy" in Act III.  And finally, the subtle feminine character of Ellen Orford, a mixture of determination and empathy.  In the middle of this triangle:  a dark, irrepressibly reactive Peter Grimes.  

[…]

What to say about José Cura? Audience members commented that they were incredibly amazed by the new performance of the Argentinian already basking in the glow of his previous appearances on the Monegasque stage:  the now legendary Stiffelio in April 2013 and more recently but equally astonishing Tannhäuser.  When the talent of an operatic artist is able to arouse genuine emotion, his repertoire can leave Giuseppe Verdi and elegantly rub shoulders with Richard Wagner and then venture with unparalleled charm into contemporary theater.  From his impressive "Alone, Alone, Alone with the Dead Child" signifying his initial despair to his final "Here you are, nearly home" through his daydreaming "In dreams, I built myself some kindlier home" in the presence of his apprentice, José Cura impresses us by the irreproachable accuracy of his tone and forces admiration by the successful vocal and dramatic expression of this inner chaos, of this incapacitating psychological surge that finds its anchor only in death.  Musicologie, 24 February 2018

 

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  The Monte Carlo Opera presented the Britten's opera Peter Grimes whose insistent and oppressive intensity is perfectly rendered.

Peter Grimes, an opera created by Benjamin Britten in 1945, is one of the composer’s most powerful.  Dramatically, the tension never fades in the adventures of this cursed fisherman who sees two of his apprentices die in accidents: the more this anti-hero seeks to silence the gossip about him, the more he gives them credence.  Musically, the score remains hectic during two hour twenty minutes of music and offers absolutely dazzling ensembles and catchy soloists.

José Cura, both directing (in charge of sets and costumes with Silvia Collazuol , and lights with Benoît Vigan) and starring in the title role in this production, offered a classic and literal point of view on the work, whose purpose, still very modern, does not need updating to find echo today. The Prologue puts Grimes on the stage in front of a white curtain on which are projected the other characters in shadows.  The rest [of the action] takes place in a building doubling as the tavern and the church, above which looms a kind of lighthouse that serves as Grimes’ home.  Installed on a turntable to quickly vary its aspects, the concept worked perfectly.

The work offers a gallery of 12 solo characters, all with vocally complex parts, musically interesting and dramatically important.  At their head, José Cura offers an interpretation that embodied Peter Grimes.  His imposing and fluid voice is torn in the high-pitched notes when he approaches them from his chest voice, which reinforces the theatrical characterization of the character’s pain.  Conversely, high notes emitted in mixed voice are strong even though they may be more fragile, especially in the "Now the Great Bear and Pleiades" where the delicate beauty of the vocal line is paramount.  On the other hand, his voice gushes in the air during the drinking scene that follows, like a flash of lightning. Ôlyrix, 21 February 2018

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  To mount Peter Grimes is to question the inner drama:  is he a victim, an executioner, or both at the same time? In this new production at the Opéra de Monte Carlo, directed by star tenor José Cura, the first option prevails, with a choice of a powerful confrontation between the fisherman and the crowd, clusters of humans moving in beautifully orchestrated choreography.  Cura offers a traditional and realistic vision of the village (with the inn and church mentioned in the libretto) in the seaside town in Suffolk.  Although very present in the music, the sea is less so in the staging, although there is a boat and the many fishing nets that litter the ground at the opening of the curtain are then raised to be suspended in the flies.  Here they will stay for the duration of the show, before being reused for the last scene, when the nets come down little by little during the last chords, trapping all the inhabitants within the village.

Previously appearing last seasons in the opera house last year in Tannhäuser, the Argentine tenor embodies a Peter Grimes trapped in his internal prison.  With his massive body folded in on itself, his clumsy and brutal gestures, Cura’s Grimes in a ball of nerves ready to explode at any moment, evincing a physical impossibility to exist, to live.  He must be heard singing a capella, his eyes fixed and misted, suddenly fragile and ready to die.  What’s more, Cura displayed dazzling vocal health, be in in the middle or high register, modulating his instrument with ease, alternating sumptuous piannissimi with heroic power with a naturalness that commands admiration.  This new role is a good one to add to Cura’s incredible list of achievements….  Opera Online, 28 February 2018

Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:  Peter Grimes culminates in the creation of the last opera character, after Wozzeck or Lulu, to touch our sensibilities, to become a myth.  Grimes is indeed a man alone; arrayed before him are not just one or two or three characters but an entire village, the “borough” from the title of George Crabbe’s poem.

Peter Grimes is the story of this great tête-à-tête between a man and everyone else, with the sea invading everything, both the stage and the music. Sailors' songs and raging seas, storms, the cries of nature and elements, the call of the marginal man whom a woman will betray, the woman who is the only one who had helped him and who, with her confession “O! Peter! We have failed,“ both abandons and murders him.

A regular on the Monegasque scene and last year’s formidable Tannhäuser, José Cura designed, in co-production with the Opera of Bonn, this Peter Grimes.  The artist assumed a protean role, singing the title role, directing, setting the staging and designing the costumes.  He created a satisfying production because he understood the scope of the complex psychology inherent the role. The ensemble is encased in good-taste classicism, the movement of the crowd is natural without awkward poses, and the star tenor approaches the hero by giving him the nuances of a Lord Byron, a sort of an uncultivated intellectual who seems animated by a poetic gift.

Of an unusual physical strength, with a voice almost too beautiful for the role, between vulnerability and contradictions, we could imagine this Grimes wreaking havoc in an English port bar…an image rejected by the Argentine to remove ambiguity [and present] a man who had suffered.  With an imagination rich enough to inspire him with the desire to live in better conditions yet constantly facing frustrations, José Cura’s Grimes marvelously expresses the torments that tear at this solitary fisherman, favoring the figure of the hopeless, the enlightened poet (it is necessary to hear his hallucination in the song in the tavern) and a surly but touched lover.  Neither hero nor villain but doubtless subtlety disruptive…..

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Videos
 

Click on photo above to watch short video

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home | Up | About | Awards and Honors | José Cura | Cover Photos | Concerts 1 | Concerts 2 | Discography | Guest Artist - Budapest | Guest Artist - Prague | Master Class | Opera Work | Opera Work 2 | Photos | Press

 

Last Updated:  Saturday, April 27, 2019  © Copyright: Kira